Hiring a new employee usually involves collecting a Social Security number and completing the required employment verification paperwork. Occasionally, an employer is given an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, or ITIN, instead of a Social Security Number (SSN). Since it looks very similar to an SSN, an employer who is unfamiliar with ITINs may assume the number can be used for employment purposes. Not everyone knows that an ITIN does not provide work authorization. The IRS issues ITINs to certain individuals who need a taxpayer identification number for federal tax purposes but are not eligible for a Social Security number.

What is an ITIN?

An Individual Taxpayer Identification Number is a nine-digit tax processing number issued by the IRS to certain people who are not eligible to obtain a Social Security number but have a federal tax reporting or filing requirement. The IRS uses ITINs for federal tax purposes. An ITIN is not a Social Security number, and having one does not provide permission to work in the United States.

IRS: Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN)

Can an Employee Work With an ITIN?

An ITIN by itself does not authorize an employee to work in the United States.

Employers need to complete the required Form I-9 process for new employees and verify employment authorization using the documents and procedures required by federal law. An ITIN should never be treated as a substitute for those documents.

Someone can have an ITIN for legitimate tax purposes and still have no authorization to work. The IRS specifically states that an ITIN does not provide legal status or the right to work in the United States.

IRS: ITIN Reminders for Tax Professionals

Employers should also avoid assuming that someone who does not have an SSN cannot legally work though. A person may be authorized to work and be in the process of obtaining an SSN. The employer still needs to follow the Form I-9 requirements and determine employment authorization based on the appropriate documents.

What If an Employee Is Authorized to Work but Does Not Have an SSN?

A situation can arise where an employee is authorized to work but has not yet received a Social Security number. For example, an employee may have recently received employment authorization and is waiting for the Social Security Administration to issue an SSN. Generally speaking, it's perfectly fine to hire a person who is authorized to work and is simply waiting for their SSN.

Social Security Administration: Social Security Numbers for Noncitizens

Why Does New York Allow ITINs on the NYS-45?

The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance's instructions for Form NYS-45 tell employers to enter an employee's nine-digit Social Security number or Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) on form NYS-45 or nine zeros if the employee does not have either number. ( NYS-45 Web File Instructions)

This adds a bit of confusion for New York employers because the wording in the state's filing instructions can lead an employer to think that an ITIN is an acceptable replacement for an SSN when putting an employee on payroll. This is not the case. New York employers must still go through the I-9 employment authorization process. The I-9 process is required in all 50 states. If an ITIN is available, and the employee is waiting for their SSN, New York says to report their wages using the ITIN. If the employee is authorized to work, does not have a SSN yet, and does not have an ITIN, the employee's wages should be reported using nine zeros as a placeholder and then later, when the SSN is issued, the employer should amend the filing.

Employers in New York who hire an employee who is not authorized to work in the United States could face penalties despite the wording used in the state's filing instructions.

Can an ITIN Be Used on an Employee's W-2?

No. An ITIN cannot be used in place of an employee's Social Security number on Form W-2.

This is where things get a bit more complicated for New York employers because New York employers are instructed by the state to report wages using an ITIN for certain employees, but the IRS instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 specifically state that employers cannot use an ITIN in place of an SSN for Federal level wage reporting.

An employer may have a legally authorized employee on payroll for months with an ITIN identifier. New York may accept the employee's ITIN on the NYS-45 and payroll may process normally, but then the W-2 filings are rejected by the Social Security Administration.

A payroll provider may then need to handle the employee's information differently for the federal W-2 filing.

How Do You Put an Employee With an ITIN on Payroll?

The answer depends partly on the payroll system being used. Some payroll systems will not allow an ITIN to be entered into the employee's SSN field at all because W-2's can't be electronically filed with an ITIN. The software may recognize the number as an ITIN because it begins with 9 and reject it.

Other payroll systems, like the one SwiftChecks provides, allow the ITIN to be entered in the employee profile. This allows New York employers to pay their ITIN employees the same exact way that they pay their employees who have SSN's. The NYS-45 can therefore be filed according to New York's filing instructions.

Should You Pay an Employee With an ITIN as a 1099?

No. Not if the claim that they are an independent contractor can't be supported. An ITIN does not make someone an independent contractor.

Payroll software has no role in determining whether someone should receive a W-2 or a 1099. If your payroll system only allows you to enter an ITIN for independent contractors, but your ITIN worker is really an employee, then you may have a problem. The willful misclassification of an employee as an independent contractor can carry significant penalties. Getting around a software limitation is not a reason for considering a worker an independent contractor and penalties for misclassifying an employee as a contractor are typically greater than penalties associated with hiring an employee who is not legally authorized to work!

The identification number and worker classification need to be treated as separate issues.

What Should a New York Employer Do If an Employee Has an ITIN?

New York can penalize an employer who files an NYS-45 with missing or invalid employee information so it's important to follow the state's filing instructions to avoid penalties. If the state's NYS-45 filing instructions say to provide a valid SSN or ITIN for each worker that is what New York employers should do.

That doesn't mean that a New York employer does not need to verify work authorization. If a New York employer hires a person who is not authorized to work in the U.S. they are opening themselves to potential penalties. All employers, regardless of the state they are operating in, should start with properly determining employment authorization.

New York may require or permit the ITIN to be reported on the NYS-45 but reporting of the ITIN on the NYS-45 is not meant to be a permanent solution. It's meant to accommodate employees who are legally allowed to work and are in the process of receiving their SSN. The federal W-2 will still require an SSN but can be e-filed with nine zeros in the SSN field as the Federal filing instructions state that this would be the equivalent of marking "Applied For" in the SSN field for that employee.

Employers should not create an SSN, alter an ITIN, use another person's SSN or change an employee's classification.

A payroll provider that understands the issue can determine how to handle the employee's information during regular payroll processing and what needs to be done before W-2s are filed.

How SwiftChecks Handles Employees With ITINs

At SwiftChecks Payroll Services, we understand the problem New York employers can run into when an employee has an ITIN instead of an SSN. Our job is to help the employer navigate payroll filing requirements without creating new problems along the way.

Our clients have direct access to a dedicated account manager, and a payroll team that takes the time to understand their business and help them work through unusual situations. You won't be left trying to figure out a complicated payroll issue by yourself or waiting for a call center to tell you what the software can and cannot do.

When an employee has an ITIN and you're unsure how to handle the payroll or reporting, give us a call.